An interview with USEF licensed small r dressage judge

Izzy 2019 Second Level

Q (ADA): What started you on the path to becoming a judge?

A (Michell Combs): When I was still new to dressage, my trainer, Cyndi Jackson, thought attending a USDF L Program would be a great way to continue my education. I had been around horses and had ridden most of my life but lacked Dressage knowledge.

Q: What was the USDF L Program experience like for you?

A: The information was incredible, and a bit overwhelming. I was fascinated, eager to learn, as well as a little intimidated. There were some formulas, some “judgements” and a lot of rules to learn. We learned what the essence of each movement in a test was, what a modifying factor was, and what the main criteria was. We had to have a better understanding of the horse’s gaits, paces and movements, in addition to putting it all that together in the blink of an eye to provide a comment and score. The testing process was mentally stressful for me. At first, I wanted to pass the programs with high scores. Then, on testing day, I just wanted to pass!

Q: Why did you decide to continue the judge training to become a USEF licensed judge?

A: I discovered that I enjoyed judging. After receiving positive feedback on my comments, scores and further remarks, it just inspired me to continue. Plus, the best way to get better as a judge is to continue to learn and get evaluated. I looked over the application to be sure I had the qualifications needed to apply and then I did!

Q: What was the USEF small r program like?

A: My group was the last small r program done through USEF. It’s now run by USDF. After applying, I waited several years to get assigned to a program. From there, I took an online program, started sitting with approved judges to learn how they do their craft, and then flew to New York for the part 1 and part 2/testing for the program. In between the two programs, which is somewhat similar to the L Program, I went to shows and judged classes. The classes I judged didn’t get scored by the show. I met with the “C” judge to be evaluated. He or she had to answer questions about my professionalism, my skills and we also had to compare how I placed the class with how that judge placed the class. For me, the hardest part is testing. It’s amazing how hard it is for me not to overthink or second guess myself, or not get intimidated about measuring up to the high standards.

Q: Now that you are a USEF licensed small r judge, what next?

A: Of course, to enjoy judging rated shows. I’ve had my small r a couple of years and now meet the requirements to join the large R program, so I’m waiting to be assigned into the new training program.

Q: What is the best part of being a judge?

A: The list is endless. I love to judge. I enjoy helping riders by providing quality comments and appropriate scores to help them with their dressage journey. I enjoy the comradery with other judges, show managers and show staff. I always enjoy the volunteers, particularly the scribe, who I spend a lot of time with at each show.  I enjoy travelling – seeing new places, new show venues, and seeing new horses and riders. I am still learning and developing my skills. Being a judge helps me become a better rider and trainer. The horse-world is a great community and judging is my way to give back to my favorite sport!

Q: What advice do you have to anyone thinking about becoming a judge?

A: Do it! If you love education and want to see the horse show world from another perspective, start by scribing to get a feel for what a judge does and what we’re responsible for. Then take the USDF L Program. It’s a great, well-thought-out program. Along the way, remember to keep your sense of humor and humility. As in riding Dressage, we’re aiming for Excellence, not Perfection!